TYSON FOODS, INC. TRADEMARKS AND REGISTERED TRADEMARKS ARE OWNED BY TYSON FOODS, INC. OR ITS SUBSIDIARIES.
Maintain Consistency Without Losing Your Pizzeria’s Signature Charm
Written by PMQ Pizza
Published: March 03, 2026
Help Boost Profits While Maintaining Brand Identity
Consistency is the foundation to build on when getting innovative with your menu. According to a 2024 Intouch Insight survey, 61 percent of consumers have switched brands after a poor customer experience, emphasizing the importance of consistency in food quality and service. For independent pizzerias especially, recognizing inconsistencies is essential. The survey also notes only 30 percent of restaurant operators agree they easily catch irregularities in individual restaurants, and less than 20 percent say they can quickly resolve issues, highlighting challenges in maintaining consistency.
“In real life, struggles with maintaining consistency are real challenges because you have the human factor,” says Brooks Cameron, Senior Executive Chef, Tyson Foodservice Culinary Team. “Some of that can be offset by training your staff, but it really helps to use Hillshire Farm products because they are really easy to train on.”
Only 30 percent of restaurant operators agree they easily catch irregularities in individual restaurants, and less than 20 percent say they can quickly resolve issues, highlighting challenges in maintaining consistency.
—Intouch Insight, 2024
Adopt Tech-Driven Systems
One way to streamline operations and scale up consistency is to adopt tech-driven systems, ensuring every pizza meets the same high standards. Kitchen display systems, for instance, are a mainstay of back-of-house communication. Automation helps reduce incorrect orders or increased ticket times and improves the consistency of food output. If four diners order pizza with premade toppings and one person orders the fettuccine alfredo special, a tech-driven system can predict how long each will take and pace the line.
Another technological innovation is recipe management systems, especially for multi-unit operators looking for consistent, authentic pizza across locations. A recipe viewer would include prep instructions, procedural protocols and training notes. The consistency scale rises when each person makes the dish the same every time. The exact scoop, slice or weight will be explicit across shifts and locations. Recipes can be changed or added across platforms or, for LTOs and seasonal offerings, allocated to whichever location is best served. This allows an independent pizzeria to be consistent but also to innovate with new items that meet the authenticity of its operation.
Look to the Menu
The menu itself is the strongest tool for an independent pizzeria to scale up consistency and showcase its charm. Leveraging premade toppings that mimic scratch-made ingredients is a way to gain consistent flavor with an eye toward authenticity. The new homemade look of Hillshire Farm® All Natural* Fully Cooked Italian Sausage Crumbles, for instance, seems like it was house-made given its varied-size pieces, craggy, irregular shape and authentic Italian sausage recipe. It’s as if Nonna is back there hand-rolling sausage for the pizza. Hillshire Farm® products are evergreen baseline staples that become the building blocks to showcase menu innovations. “The staples are always relevant, but the question becomes, ‘What do you do with pepperoni?’ So you’ll see the Pepperoni 100 or the kinds of things on TikTok and social media. Instead of having just a regular pepperoni pizza, now some of it’s cooked on the pizza and some of it’s also roasted off to the side and added over the top like a textural element. I think that there are areas to play inside of a traditional build,” Cameron says.
Independent pizzerias who bank on unique, authentic menu items won’t lose their credibility but will rather free up time to focus on those recipes or tasks that are more time-consuming. “Independent pizzerias have more opportunity to play. And as we watch pizza trends, a lot of mid-level operators are going to have more than one unit. They’re not constrained by owning a franchise or someone from corporate telling them exactly what they have to do. They’re big enough that they know how to operate and keep consistency between stores. Hillshire Farm products can help with having consistent stores, and then you can go play and have fun,” Cameron says.
The key is finding ways to maintain consistency while keeping labor in check. While many chefs are admired for scratch-made offerings, pizza toppings don’t have to be one of them. Hillshire Farm® toppings are crafted with high-quality ingredients to offer exceptional flavor and consistency over scratch-made in terms of taste, portion, training and price point.
“Consistency in the Hillshire Farm product line will help build customer trust in what you’re doing, and a lot of that gives you the freedom to go and create. It gives you the buy-in that your customer is going to say, ‘Well, okay, every time I come here, the pepperoni pizza is on point. So this time, maybe I’m going to try the hot honey version.’ It might not sound like a huge step, but for a lot of diners, it is,” Cameron says. “If you get a consistent product every time your customer comes in, they’re going to have a great experience. They’ll be expecting that same great experience every time.”
Learn more today about creating menu consistency with the help of Hillshire Farm® brand.
